Credit Rating and NBFC Governance Post-IL&FS and DHFL
By: admin
Articles

Credit Rating and NBFC Governance Post-IL&FS and DHFL
The 2018 and 2019 stress episodes at major NBFCs including IL&FS and DHFL fundamentally reshaped how rating agencies, regulators, and the market weigh governance quality in NBFC credit assessment, with considerably more rigorous scrutiny of board independence, related-party transactions, and disclosure quality applied in the years since.
What Happened and Why It Mattered So Much
Beginning in 2018, a major infrastructure-focused NBFC group faced a severe liquidity and solvency crisis driven by a combination of asset-liability mismatches, discussed in the dedicated ALM article elsewhere in this pillar, and governance concerns, triggering a broader loss of market confidence in the NBFC sector that affected funding access across many otherwise sound NBFCs. A separate housing finance company faced its own significant stress episode the following year, involving governance and related-party transaction concerns that came to light during that period. Together, these episodes represent a pivotal moment in Indian NBFC sector history that materially reshaped subsequent regulatory and rating practice.
How These Episodes Changed Rating Practice
Following these episodes, rating agencies, alongside regulators, applied considerably more rigorous scrutiny to NBFC governance quality specifically — board independence and effectiveness, the nature and extent of related-party transactions, the quality and timeliness of financial disclosure, and auditor independence and rotation practices — treating governance as a more explicitly weighted, independently assessed factor rather than a secondary consideration behind financial metrics alone, a shift broadly consistent with the heightened governance emphasis also reflected in RBI's subsequent scale-based regulatory framework discussed elsewhere in this pillar.
Related-Party Transaction Scrutiny
Given that related-party transaction concerns featured in these historical stress episodes, rating agencies now generally apply particularly close scrutiny to an NBFC's related-party lending and transaction disclosure, looking for genuine arm's-length terms, appropriate board and audit committee oversight, and transparent disclosure, with any significant, inadequately explained related-party exposure treated as a meaningful governance red flag warranting close investigation.
Board Independence and Risk Management Function Maturity
Rating agencies also assess the genuine independence and effectiveness of an NBFC's board, including whether independent directors demonstrate meaningful oversight rather than a purely formal presence, and the maturity of the NBFC's internal risk management function, including whether risk management has genuine authority and visibility at the board level rather than being subordinate to a growth-focused business function — governance quality dimensions that are, by their nature, more qualitative and judgement-based than the quantitative metrics discussed throughout the rest of this pillar, but which rating agencies now treat as genuinely significant following the lessons of these past episodes.
Illustrative Example
Consider a hypothetical NBFC with a demonstrably independent, actively engaged board, transparent and clearly arm's-length related-party dealings fully disclosed and reviewed by its audit committee, and a risk management function with genuine board-level visibility and authority to challenge business growth decisions. Its rating agency's assessment specifically credits this governance maturity as a meaningful positive factor in its own right, reflecting the heightened post-2018 emphasis on governance discussed in this article, in contrast to a hypothetical peer NBFC where the rating agency's review identifies several related-party transactions with limited independent scrutiny and a risk management function that appears to have limited practical influence over the company's aggressive growth strategy — governance weaknesses the rating agency explicitly cites as a significant independent factor in a cautious rating action, separate from and in addition to any concerns about the NBFC's financial metrics.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do governance concerns alone lead to a rating downgrade, even with strong financial metrics?
Yes, following the lessons of the historical episodes discussed in this article, rating agencies now generally treat significant governance weaknesses as an independently significant negative factor capable of driving rating action even where reported financial metrics appear sound, given how these historical episodes demonstrated that governance weaknesses can precede and eventually drive genuine financial deterioration.
How do rating agencies assess board independence in practice?
This generally involves reviewing board composition, attendance and engagement patterns, the substantive content of board and committee discussions where disclosed, and evidence of the board genuinely challenging or scrutinising management decisions rather than simply ratifying them.
Are related-party transactions always a red flag?
Not inherently — related-party transactions conducted transparently, at arm's-length terms, with appropriate independent oversight are a normal feature of many corporate groups; the concern arises specifically from inadequately disclosed, non-arm's-length, or poorly governed related-party dealings.
Has NBFC sector governance broadly improved since these episodes?
Market and regulatory developments since these episodes, including RBI's scale-based regulatory framework discussed elsewhere in this pillar, suggest meaningful broad improvement in sector governance practices, though rating agencies continue to assess each NBFC's specific governance quality individually rather than assuming uniform improvement across the sector.
Talk to FinMen Advisors — for help preparing for a rating exercise, write to marketing@finmen.in or call +91 77387 14680.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, credit, investment, or legal advice. Credit ratings are assigned solely by SEBI-registered Credit Rating Agencies (such as CRISIL, ICRA, CARE Ratings, India Ratings, Brickwork, Acuite, and Infomerics) based on their own methodologies, policies, and the information available to them at the time of assessment. FinMen Advisors provides preparatory and advisory support to companies undergoing a rating exercise and does not issue, influence, or guarantee any rating outcome. Readers should exercise independent judgement and consult qualified professionals before making business or financial decisions.





